The "Arrow" Scene I Won't Stop Complaining About

I swear, this comes up about once ever other month, where I'm working with a newer student on Double Sinawali, and I'm reminded of this scene from "Arrow", a superhero tv show that ran on the CW network here in the US from 2012-2020.
Of course I watched it. I'm a nerd.
Please do take a moment and watch the thing (it's only 36 seconds long). Audio is not strictly required but it absolutely, positively enhances the experience of WHY I WON'T STOP TALKING ABOUT IT years and years later.
Over 36 damn seconds.
Anway, experience it for yourself.
If you haven't seen the show, the shirtless guy is Oliver Queen, the Green Arrow, and the other guy is John Diggle, his best friend (and a vigilante himself called Spartan on the show).
~ TAKES A DEEP BREATH ~
Let's start with the positives first.
It'll be short.
As an Arnis player I am thrilled to see obvious Filipino Martial Arts in television and movies, although they rarely, if ever, identify it as Filipino Martial Arts, and other arts end up getting the credit (even on the embedded video's title - Silat? NO.)
Having a pop culture reference for people who don't know what I do when I'm telling them about it is very helpful.
~Tries hard to think of more positives, comes up empty~
And now, let's talk about how ANNOYING THIS SCENE IS. I realize it's a fantasy TV show (one long gone by this writing so my complaints are a day late, a dollar short). I KNOW that this is not realistic and not supposed to be realistic. I know how action scenes are shot and choreographed (and appreciate those things for what they are).
BUT.
Stuff like the things in this scene is how we end up with teenage boys hurting each other in their back yards imitating this nonsense, thinking they're actually training. I have had actual students in my school that I have had to explain this to, more than once, so I know this to be true (not to mention how social media is full of kids doing this stuff).
THE METAL BARS AS TRAINING WEAPONS
What the actual f....?
Okay, look, rattan is a training material that's traditional, but it's also inexpensive and relatively safe. I realize it doesn't make cool bang-bang sounds like metal bars, but it's still a pretty cool clack-clack sound, especially with new, not-beaten-up, taped-up sticks (like most of mine usually are).
You get hit with rattan, it sucks and hurts (everyone who's ever sparred with rattan is smiling at the memory of the WELTS), but BAD injuries are very rare.
The metal bars are a "we gotta make this cooler for the dumb fans" Hollywood thing that doesn't really add anything to the scene, and in my opinion (given what happens later) gives a completely stupid take on what martial arts training is like, especially modern FMA's.
Martial arts training of all kinds allows people to FAIL (repeatedly), so they can learn.
If Oliver or Diggle accidentally smashes a finger or a hand (which happens ALL THE DAMN TIME, especially with newbies), I promise you, bones are going to be broken, maybe even crushed. That knocks you out of training for a looong time as you heal (neither of these guys are superheroes with magical healing powers, they're all basically Batman-type characters), and it's very possible the grip may be compromised FOREVER.
Later, there's a point where Oliver DELIBERATELY hits Diggle in the HEAD with the metal bar to make a point (about 9 seconds in). Diggle goes "Ahhhh!" in response, takes a few seconds to recover while Oliver lectures him (more on that later), Diggle says, "That wasn't nice, where'd you learn that?" and then have a short conversation, then they go back to training.

It's hard to see (because they hide it with the angle of the shot because no way did that prop - probably a foam stick - actually touch the actor) but given Diggle's reaction, narratively, it looks like a fast, full-power shot straight across the jaw.
With a metal bar this would dislocate the jaw at a minimum. It might actually crush several bones in his skull. That's potentially FATAL.
GET OUTTA HERE, ARROW.
THE TRAINING METHODOLOGY ITSELF
Okay, so of course this is not a realistic training session nor is it supposed to be.
It's to show off some cool, deadly-looking FMA moves while getting Diggle (and the audience) caught up a little on what's been going on with Oliver Queen (I'm not going into that here, watch the show).
That being said...
First off, they're doing a two-man (usually cooperative) drill we call sinawali, which is stuff I teach white belts and that we emphasize as a drill on our beginner level. The pattern is basically "Heaven Six".
Here's people engaging in "Heaven Six" in a competent way:
Note that their arms are not straight out from their bodies and they don't keep their hands mostly out in the middle space between them.
Unlike Mr. "Superhero trained by a deadly expert assassin guy" Oliver Queen.
Anyhoo, Diggle takes a swipe at Oliver (WHY?!?!?!) - who is RIDICULOUSLY out of range and is in little to no danger even if he didn't dramatically lean back - overswings and imbalances himself, exposing his back (and the back of his head) to an opponent with a metal freaking bar.
Oliver says, "Think of the rear hand, Diggle."
Which literally has diddly squat to do with how Diggle just made an obvious shot on an obvious line of attack completely and totally out of range and missed, to the surprise of only himself.
He might as well has said, "Think of the waxing gibbous moon, Diggle" or "Think of the color of underwear you're wearing, Diggle" and it would have made exactly the same amount of sense.
Let's talk about that swipe to Oliver's head, and then Oliver's counter attack back a few seconds later that actually lands, and then later, Oliver hits Diggle by surprise again, this time a low strike to the leg.
In training, I, as an instructor - or even a friend, as these two are supposed to be - would never, ever, ever, ever EVER try to deliberately hit the person I'm training with without warning, especially not a student who depends on me to keep them safe while they train.
And I definitely wouldn't aim for a target as risky as the head (what if my targeting isn't perfect - students MOVE, y'know - and I hit them in the eye and they LOSE THE EYE?).
I wouldn't do it with rattan. I wouldn't do it with a padded stick. I definitely wouldn't do it with a metal-freakin'-pipe to a vulnerable spot to a FRIEND, much less my VERY BEST FRIEND.
The leg shot is less dangerous, but still, a total dick move on Oliver's part.
If I had a training partner or instructor do that stuff to me, assuming I didn't get seriously injured, I wouldn't train with them any more, at a minimum. I might even look into if I can get them charged with assault.
You've read up to this point, and you're thinking, "But Chick, it's a freaking dumb fantasy TV show, one off the air for years now, get a damn grip and stop taking it so seriously."
And you're right. It's ridiculous that I care about it at all, much less, enough to spend the time to deconstruct a single clip and then write about it, years after it went off the air.
However, as a self-respecting raging nerd about both fantasy television AND the martial arts, I really, really wish there'd be more decent, safe, semi-realistic (but also cool looking) martial arts material in popular media, especially Filipino Martial Arts (that are CALLED WHAT THEY ARE versus implied being some magical kung-fu thing).
I'll get off my soapbox, for now, but I assure all y'all I will definitely be referring to this bullshit scene at least once in class within the next six months, even though I get blank looks from about 90% of my students now. Imagine what it'll be like in 20 more years.
Because I'll still be complaining about it.




Comments